Overview
The German Whistleblower Protection Act (Hinweisgeberschutzgesetz, HinSchG) transposes the EU Whistleblower Directive in Germany. It has applied since 2 July 2023 and requires employers with 50 or more employees to set up an internal reporting channel. Reporting persons are protected against retaliation, and a reversal of the burden of proof applies in case of detriment.
Germany went well beyond the directive: the HinSchG protects reports on all criminal offences and many administrative offences – not only breaches of EU law.
Who Is Covered?
| Employer | Obliged since |
|---|---|
| 250 or more employees | 02.07.2023 (fines since 01.12.2023) |
| 50 to 249 employees | 17.12.2023 |
| Investment firms, credit institutions, payment and e-money institutions, asset management companies, insurers and others | regardless of size |
What counts is the number of employees as a rule – the headcount typical for the business, including part-time staff and apprentices. Each legal entity is obliged on its own; authorities, municipalities and public undertakings are covered as well.
What Can Be Reported?
The HinSchG covers, among other things:
- all criminal offences
- administrative offences where the rule protects life, limb, health or employee rights – such as occupational safety or minimum wage
- breaches of EU and national law in the areas of the directive: money laundering, product safety, environment, food, consumer protection, data protection, IT security, public procurement, financial services, competition law, corporate tax and more
- statements by civil servants that breach their duty of loyalty to the constitution
Requirements for the Internal Reporting Channel
- Independence and expertise: the responsible persons must be able to act independently and have the necessary expertise; other duties are allowed as long as no conflicts of interest arise.
- Channels: reports must be possible orally or in text form; on request, a personal meeting must be arranged, with consent also by video.
- Confidentiality: the identity of the reporting person, the persons concerned and other persons named must be protected.
- Documentation: every report is documented in a retrievable way and deleted three years after the procedure is closed.
- Information: staff must receive clear, easily accessible information on internal and external reporting procedures.
How a report is handled
- Acknowledgement within 7 days
- Check whether the breach is in scope, and contact with the reporting person
- Follow-up, such as an internal investigation, referral to an authority or closure for lack of evidence
- Feedback within 3 months of the acknowledgement
Outsourcing and Group Solutions
The channel’s tasks can be assigned to third parties – such as an ombudsperson, a law firm or a specialised provider. Employers with 50 to 249 employees may also run a shared reporting channel.
According to the explanatory memorandum, another group company can also act as a third party (the “group privilege”). Each company nevertheless remains responsible for remedying breaches. Because the European Commission views pure group-level solutions critically, reports should also be possible at subsidiary level.
External Reporting Channels
- Federal Office of Justice – federal external reporting office for all areas without special responsibility
- BaFin – financial services, money laundering in the financial sector, financial reporting and auditing
- Federal Cartel Office – competition law and the Digital Markets Act
- External channels of the federal states for state and municipal authorities
Reporting persons may choose freely whether to report internally or externally. The Act recommends preferring internal reporting where the breach can be dealt with effectively internally and no retaliation is to be feared.
Protection Against Retaliation
Retaliation is prohibited – including threats and attempts. If a reporting person suffers a work-related detriment after a report, it is presumed to be retaliation. The employer then has to prove that the measure was based on sufficiently justified grounds.
Breaches give rise to a claim for damages, but not to a claim for employment or promotion. Conversely, anyone who intentionally or grossly negligently reports false information is liable for the resulting damage.
Fines
| Offence | Fine up to |
|---|---|
| Obstructing a report (including attempts) | EUR 50,000 |
| Taking retaliatory measures (including attempts) | EUR 50,000 |
| Breaching confidentiality intentionally or recklessly | EUR 50,000 |
| Not setting up and operating an internal channel | EUR 20,000 |
| Knowingly disclosing false information | EUR 20,000 |
| Breaching confidentiality negligently | EUR 10,000 |
For obstructing reports, retaliation and intentional or reckless breaches of confidentiality, the fine against companies can be multiplied by ten under section 30 of the Administrative Offences Act – up to EUR 500,000.
Differences from the Austrian HSchG
| HinSchG (Germany) | HSchG (Austria) | |
|---|---|---|
| Material scope | EU areas plus all criminal offences and certain administrative offences | EU areas plus corruption (sections 302–309 Criminal Code) |
| Fine for missing channel | up to EUR 20,000 | none |
| Maximum fine | EUR 50,000 per offence | EUR 20,000, repeat EUR 40,000 |
| Anonymous reports | should be processed | no duty |
| Retention | deletion 3 years after closure | 5 years, longer during ongoing proceedings |
| External channel | Federal Office of Justice | BAK |
| Burden of proof for retaliation | presumption in favour of the reporting person | credibility, “higher probability” |
Details on the Austrian law: HSchG – Whistleblower Protection in Austria.
Checklist for German Companies
- Check headcount per company and the financial sector exceptions
- Choose a model: own channel, shared channel (50–249 employees), group solution or external ombudsperson
- Appoint the responsible persons and ensure independence and expertise
- Set up channels – oral and in text form, ideally anonymous and available around the clock
- Define the procedure: 7 days acknowledgement, 3 months feedback, documentation, deletion after 3 years
- Carry out a data protection impact assessment and handle data subject rights
- Involve the works council (section 87(1) Works Constitution Act)
- Inform staff about internal and external reporting channels and train managers on the prohibition of retaliation
More on the legal situation in Germany: EU regulations in Germany.
Legal sources
Frequently Asked Questions
From how many employees does the HinSchG apply?
Employers with, as a rule, at least 50 employees must set up an internal reporting channel. For 250 or more employees this has applied since 2 July 2023, for 50 to 249 employees since 17 December 2023. Certain financial companies are covered regardless of size.
What is the fine for not having an internal reporting channel?
Up to EUR 20,000. This fine can be imposed since 1 December 2023. Fines are considerably higher for obstructing reports, retaliation and breaches of confidentiality: up to EUR 50,000, and up to EUR 500,000 against companies under section 30 of the Administrative Offences Act.
Does the channel have to allow anonymous reports?
No. The internal reporting channel should process anonymous reports but does not have to offer a channel that enables them. In practice, many companies still use anonymous channels because they increase employees' trust.
May a parent company run the reporting channel for all subsidiaries?
According to the German legislator, yes: another group company can be appointed as a third party to perform the channel's tasks. Each subsidiary remains responsible for remedying breaches, and reports must also be possible there. The European Commission views pure group-level solutions critically.
Which authority is the external reporting channel in Germany?
The federal external reporting office at the Federal Office of Justice. BaFin is responsible for financial matters, the Federal Cartel Office for competition law. The federal states can set up their own external channels for state and municipal administrations.
How long may a report be stored?
The documentation must be deleted three years after the procedure is closed. It may be kept longer if this is necessary and proportionate to meet requirements of the HinSchG or other laws.
Does the works council have to be involved?
As a rule, yes. Introducing a reporting channel touches co-determination rights under section 87(1) of the Works Constitution Act, for example on rules of conduct and technical systems. Whether a channel is set up at all, however, is required by law.